Related
Among authoritative phantasy worlds , one of the most beloved isHarry Potter , yet as much as readers adore the wizarding world , there are a number of aspects of it that really make no sense . Harry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stonewas first written in 1997 and spawnedsix more novel , all of which followed the young wizard , Harry , as he attended wizarding school and fought against Lord Voldemort . The Word were quickly adapted into movies , boost the enfranchisement ’s popularity even more . Now , consecrate viewers know all the ins and outs of Harry ’s world , including the logical holes .
It is n’t needfully strange for fantasy stories to have logistical error . When an author creates an integral humanity from scratch , it can be unmanageable to cover every face of a living and breathing society . Yet , it has to be admitted thatHarry Potterhas quite a few elements that never quite pan off out , and still raise interrogation to this mean solar day about howthe wizarding world , otherwise screw as the Potterverse , actually work . From muggles to Hogwarts classes , theHarry Potterbooks never quite flesh out the daily workings of a real community .
10Where Do Wizards Work
Is The Ministry Of Magic The Only Place To Work?
One major doubtfulness thatHarry Potteraudiences have about the wizarding earth is where wizards work . While the serial shows professors at Hogwarts and notes the many job withinthe Ministry of Magic , it is entirely clear what other job chance there are for whiz . Some own shops like Ollivander ’s or work for the governing , like Arthur Weasley , butHarry Potternever really delves into all the choice for wizards and witches . The serial does n’t even refer whether wizards go to university .
This scenario makes it clear that , althoughHarry Potterfocuses heavy on wizarding education , the series never quite explain what all of this schooling is result to .
Of of course , the question of wizarding jobs does n’t make or breakHarry Potter , but it definitely leaves a rather self-aggrandising yap within wizarding society . It does n’t seem right that thaumaturgist must be business sector possessor , Quidditch players , or government employee . This scenario makes it clear that , althoughHarry Potterfocuses heavy on wizarding education , the series never quite explains what all of this schooling is leading to . sorcerer may even have muggle job , butHarry Potterisn’t concerned in answering this question , among others .
9How Many Students Attend Hogwarts
What J.K. Rowling Has Said About Hogwarts' Student Population
Another major question lector have about Hogwarts in particular is how many students go there . fit in toHarry Potter and the Sorcerer ’s Stone , there are 40 students in Harry ’s year , and each house experience ten student . However , if this were the fount for every year , there would only be 280 students in total . Yet , throughout the serial , Hogwarts ' student consistence seems to have upwards of a thousand students . The movies definitely make this seem true . So , what is the truth ?
Ever marvel what life would be like in the Wizarding World ? These Harry Potter quizzes will tell you which house you would be in at Hogwarts !
at long last , it seems as though the numbers deepen depending on the book to better jibe the tale at paw . Perhaps it made sense for Harry to be among 39 other first - years , but by and by on , the student body had to mature bigger for consequence like the Battle of Hogwarts and the Triwizard Tournament . One line of reasoning that takes the exercising weight off of these shifting numbers is the theory thatHarry ’s class was peculiarly small because of Voldemort ’s attacks a decade before .
8Unbreakable Vows
Why Don’t Wizards Use Them More?
Among the manyspells that appear inHarry Potter , one of the most queerly utilized ace was the Unbreakable Vow . InHarry Potter and the Half - Blood Prince , Severus Snape enters an Unbreakable Vow with Narcissa Malfoy that forces Snape to protect Draco Malfoy at all toll , and eventually , kill Dumbledore when Draco can not . The rules of the Unbreakable Vow state that Snape must follow out his promises , and if he does n’t , he will die . Yet , for such a muscular spell , the stake of Snape ’s vow seem pretty downhearted .
The big question around the Unbreakable Vow is why it was n’t used more often throughout the serial publication . Considering Voldemort ’s relationship with his Death Eaters , it would make signified that he would ask Unbreakable Vowsfrom all of them , but he does n’t . Furthermore , Draco could have been the one to take the vow , which would have forced him to kill Dumbledore to economise his own life . Clearly , the Unbreakable Vow was created simply soSnape would murder Dumbledore , regardless of the fact that it opens so many other threshold for magician .
7Do Wizards Learn Math, English, Science, Etc.
Hogwarts Classes Explained
One major plot hole inHarry Potteris whether wizards learn basic subject like maths , skill , and English . Based on Harry ’s story , it seems that wizard schooling starts at age 11 and lasts until eld 18 . This begs the question : what do wizards do for the first ten of their life?Presumably , Harry went to muggle school during his puerility , and perhaps purebloods like the Malfoys were homeschooled . Even then , math and English are skills that are necessary even beyond the grade school level , yet they did n’t seem to be present at Hogwarts .
Class
Type
verbal description
defensive measure Against the Dark Arts
required
Defensive instruction against dark magic trick and creatures
Transfiguration of Jesus
Spellwork of transforming one thing into another , including human shift
Harry Potter is a multimedia franchise about an orphaned boy who enrolls at Hogwarts School of Wizardry, where he learns the truth about himself, his family, and the terrible evil that haunts the magical world. Adapted from the novels, Harry Potter is an eight-episode film saga that follows the journey of Harry Potter and his friends, Hermoine Granger and Ron Weasley, as they navigate the tricky world of growing up, school life, and magic. Starting from year one and moving to their seventh year, the films chronicle the students' time at Hogwarts while unfurling a sinister plot that centers around the unsuspecting Harry. With the return of the dark wizard, Voldemort, the students and professors at Hogwarts will fight to carry on as the world around them may change forever. Harry Potter has expanded beyond the world of its films and novels with several video games, a spin-off film series titled Fantastic Beasts, and even attractions at Universal Studios.
appeal
Spellwork of magical effect on things and masses ; covering all spells not categorise under another issue
potion
Preparation of pseudo - chemical concoction that will produce magical effects
Herbology
Study of magical plant , including concern and their economic consumption
Astronomy
subject of the champion and planet and their charming influence
History of Magic
Covering significant historical outcome of the Wizarding earth
Care of Magical Creatures
Elective
Study of charming creatures , including instruction in care and safety
fortune telling
The practice of discerning the future from certain magical phenomenon
Arithmancy
The discipline of the magical properties of numeral
Ancient Runes
Language class on the ABC used by Bronze & Iron Age wizards
Muggle Studdies
The study of non - magical culture and technology
Flying
Supplementary course of instruction
One - off path taught to first - year on the basics of aviate
Apparition
12 - hebdomad course offered by the Ministry of Magic to sixth and seventh years on Apparition , the ability to travel instantly from one localization to another ; necessary to obtain an apparition licence
The most obvious understanding for this logistical wrongdoing is thatthose form would not be nearly as interesting to read about as Potions or Transfiguration . It would n’t make sense for Rowling to waste metre on science class when Defense Against the Dark Arts is so much more predominant to the plot . Furthermore , proofreader can assume that sure field of study could have fold intoHogwart ’s witching classes . maven need mathematics to successfully create potions and take English to write good essays for their O.W.L.S.
6Slytherins Always Being Considered Bad
Slytherins Deserved More Characterization
A complaint that has long plagued theHarry Pottercommunity isthe Hogwarts Houses , and in fussy , Slytherins . From the very beginning , Rowling made it quite clear that the Slytherin family was for malefic characters only . Despite being known as ambitious and tricky , these Slytherin traits were never redact positively , but instead , just made the Slytherin characters untrustworthy . While this worked for the story at script , it does n’t quite tear apart out when the wizarding world as a whole is look at .
If every offender came from Slytherin house , it would make sense that the wizarding world would discover this , and do something about it .
The major dubiousness that orb around the Slytherins is why Hogwarts had an evil mansion in the first blank space . If every wrongdoer came from Slytherin house , it would make sentiency that the wizarding world would mark this , and do something about it . Generally , it is also just an unfair word-painting . Ambition is not an inherently sorry trait , andRowling should have included some good Slytherins to prove that Draco and his buddy were simply outliers .
5What Is Legal & Illegal For Wizards
Time Turners, Love Potions, & Flying Carpets
ThroughoutHarry Potter , there are emphatically rule about what wizards can and can not do , yet even some of these legal philosophy are cockeyed . For example , fly carpets are illegal inHarry Potterbecause they are considered to be muggle object . Yet , the Weasley twins are capable to sell sexual love potions at their store , and booze these could get an someone into a very dicey situationthat is non - consensual . Similarly , Hermione well uses a time - turner inHarry Potter in the Prisoner of Azkaban , despite the fact that mess with time hail with monumental consequences .
Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban introduced time - food turner , which allow the user to travel in time , but these were n’t used again .
Once again , this seems to be a pillowcase of Rowling including new magical item for the benefit of the story without really considering how they would affect the wizarding world at large . Hermione ’s use of the clock time - food turner is amazing for the fib at hand , yet it raises query as to why no one went back in time and attempt to kill Voldemortbefore he was even born . Ultimately , this is one of the most disappointing plot pickle because it simply was n’t recall - out enough .
4Poverty, Hunger, & More For Wizards
Magic Should Solve Everything
ManyHarry Potterlovers have question why poverty , hunger , and other job have plagued wizardswhen they have thaumaturgy at their fingertips . WithinHarry Potter , it is impossible for a wizard to magically make solid food , yet transfiguration could well puzzle out this problem . A whiz could take any object and transfigure it into something eatable . The same goes for money . Logically , a wizard would be capable to transfigure anything into Au .
3How Wizards & Muggles Co-Exist (Or Don’t)
Wizards Should Understand Muggles More
A Brobdingnagian problem withinHarry Potteris the relationship between muggles and wizards . Although wizards seem to have their own communities and bloodlines , the existence of muggle - Max Born and half - bloods completely interrupt the mind of a wizard - only society . Wizards like Harry and Hermione do not experience in closing off , but are around muggles always . The same must be honest for other wizards , perhaps even purebloods . So , it does n’t make sense for wizards to be so blind to muggle problems and idea , because muggles and maven pretty much have to co - be .
This brings up another event about wizarding acculturation . At Hogwarts , there are a admixture of pureblood pupil and muggle born student . In this direction , it would make sense for muggleborn wizards to fetch elements of the muggle world into Hogwarts , including medicine , TV shows , and worldwide democratic polish . It seems improbable that muggleborns would simply allow for all that behind to be a wizard . Yet , Harry Potternever includes this type of crossing , and it is honestly a shame readers never suffer to see this .
2No Technology In The Wizarding World
Wizards Have Some Tech But Not Others
One of the most popular swage within theHarry Potterfranchise is that the wizarding world seems to have petty technology . Although the books take position during the nineties , star seem to be living in the past times in a number of slipway . They still use quills and ink , they communicate via owl rather than telephone set , and most wizards do not have cars . While these are framed as simple oddity of wizarding life story , they also bring up some rather significant issues of convenience for wizards . If transportation and communication are so difficult , it ’s a admiration that the wizarding world even function .
Wizards may have magic , but much of their culture is old - school and slowly - paced .
In many ways , necromancer are characterize as being better or ahead of muggles , but their lack of engineering science pound a massive hole in this theme . Wizards may have magic , but much of their cultivation is old - school and tardily - paced . Using bird of Minerva and taking a magical train emphatically have their good luck charm , but it also makes wizards outliers of society at with child . Muggles technology certainly has a leg - up over magicwhen it amount to the general function of a society .
1Muggles Not Noticing Magic
Magic Cannot Hide Completely
What is in all likelihood the hardest concept to believe inHarry Potteris that muggles know nothing about magic . There are a few intellect for this . First and foremost , Harry himself gets into so many publicly idle situations that it pee no sentience that muggles would continue absolutely clueless . Wizards would have to do a lot of skilled Obliviating to keep their existence a arcanum . Furthermore , the existence of muggle - borns also hurts this theory . If two muggles give birth to a wizard , it seems too perfect that they would always keep this to themselves . Their compeer would almost certainly have questions .
Warner Bros has badger some new details about the story of HBO ’s forthcoming Harry Potter remaking , and it prognosticate well for the Wizarding World franchise .
Above all , humans are inherently curious existence . Academics and scientists have always been interested in how thing work and what live beyond humans . There is lilliputian doubt that mankind would be just as eager to learn about magicas they are to see about aliens and what happens after demise . In this way , this is the biggest defect of theHarry Potterfranchise , at least when it comes to the inner working of the wizarding world .
Harry Potter is a multimedia system franchise about an orphan son who enter at Hogwarts School of Wizardry , where he learns the truth about himself , his kinsperson , and the severe evil that haunt the witching world . Adapted from the novels , Harry Potter is an eight - episode cinema saga that follows the journey of Harry Potter and his friends , Hermoine Granger and Ron Weasley , as they pilot the slippery world of grow up , school life sentence , and magic . Starting from year one and move to their seventh year , the moving picture chronicle the students ' time at Hogwarts while unfurling a sinister patch that centers around the unsuspecting Harry . With the riposte of the dark wizard , Voldemort , the students and professor at Hogwarts will oppose to transmit on as the public around them may change incessantly . Harry Potter has expanded beyond the world of its motion-picture show and novels with several video games , a twirl - off film serial titled Fantastic beast , and even attractions at Universal Studios .
