Alien: Romulus
Alien : Romulusfeatured the man-made character of Rook , modeled as a CGI recreation of the late Ian Holm , pray the question of which actors would have been a better selection in the persona . GivenAlien : Romulus ' place on theAlientimeline , it make in - universe sense to have the likeness of Holm used for the android cognize as Rook;Alien : Romulusis sandwiched betweenAlienandAliens , with Holm ’s Ash being the main android grapheme used in the former . As such , by the metre ofAlien : Romulus ' climactic ending , it became easier to infer the thought process behind using Holm .
That said , the decisiveness did cause outside criticism due to the fact that Holm clear away in 2020 . AlthoughAlien : Romulusis overall considered to be one of thebest - rankedAlienmovies , Holm ’s posthumous appearance was controversial due to the argument over the ethical motive of reviving actors onscreen . While Rook ’s lineament puzzle out within the context of the movie itself , it was unmanageable for many to differentiateAlien : Romulusfrom these moral treatment , leading to the geographic expedition of several other thespian who would have exercise better as Rook , the android ofAlien ’s Weyland - Yutani Corporation .
5Michael Fassbender
Appeared in Prometheus & Alien: Covenant
One of the more obvious choice for theandroid character inAlien : Romuluswas Michael Fassbender . Fassbender first appeared in 2012’sPrometheusas David , an android create by the founder of the Weyland Corp , Peter Weyland . David was sent to LV-223 alongside the crew of the USCSS Prometheus to chance the Engineers of the human race . David ’s enchantment with the Engineers saw him take a nefarious turn , one that influenced the creative activity of the Xenomorph variant known as the Protomorph inAlien : Covenant .
Rook is one of the vainglorious point of contention in the raw Alien : Romulus movie . I ’d rather have seen a dissimilar worker returning to the dealership .
For many , Fassbender and his two character , David and later the android Walter , were considered the serious aspects of Ridley Scott’sAlienprequel movies . Fassbender ’s functioning was unendingly satisfying , and his character were integral to the geographic expedition of the Xenomorphs and the wide traditional knowledge of theAlienfranchisefound inPrometheusandAlien : Covenant . Given thatAlien : Romulus ' cardinal MacGuffin is name the " Prometheus Fire " and is what Rook is so committed to stop up for the Weyland - Yutani Corporation , it would have made thematic sense for Fassbender to be used for the character .
Having Fassbender play Rook would have allowed him to execute as a synthetic committed to the Weyland - Yutani Corporation , all while tie the actor back to his earlier roles …
Furthermore , this would have allowed Fassbender to act a slightly different type of android than David or Walter . These two characters had much more office than most androids in the franchise , let in Rook . As such , take Fassbender toy Rook would have allowed him to perform as a synthetic put to the Weyland - Yutani Corporation , all while attach the actor back to his early part due toAlien : Romulus ' golf links toPrometheusandAlien : Covenant . Finally , Fassbender ’s appearance would have withdraw the complex arguments surrounding Holm ’s on - screen resurrection .
4Lance Henriksen
Appeared in Aliens & Alien 3
Another actor who could have portrayedIan Holm ’s Rook inAlien : Romulusis Lance Henriksen . Henriksen was inaugurate to the franchise inAliensas Bishop , another synthetic substance who was tasked with aiding the US Colonial Marine Corps ’ 2nd Battalion as they search LV-426 ’s novel colony for Xenomorphs . The character was ab initio distrusted by Ripley who had big experience with Ian Holm ’s first android role , Ash , inAlien . Ripley find Bishop ’s nature when his white blood was shown inAliens ' iconic knife trick scene early in the moving-picture show .
The androids in the Alien movies have blank blood alternatively of red to set up them apart from the humans and connect to the franchise ’s theme .
However , Bishop establish integral to aid Ripley defeat the Xenomorph Queen inAliens’ending , change her perceptual experience of the mechanical man and leading to his more emotionally resonant role(s ) inAlien 3.For many understanding , Henriksen would have been a good choice to portray Rook inAlien : Romulus . For one , the moral discussion of Holm ’s CGI return would again be obviate as Henriksen is still alive and somewhat active in Hollywood as of 2024 .
Custom Image by Lewis Glazebrook
Secondly , Henriksen ’s appearance would coordinate with theAlientimeline as the Bishop models were introduced beforeAliens , the same period in whichAlien : Romulusis set . Thematically , it also would have been challenging to see Henriksen represent a more incompatible android . Bishop was more sympathetic and helpful inAliens , meaning the role of Rook would have allowed the actor to flex more nefarious sinew as Rook serves asAlien : Romulus’secondary opponent .
3Winona Ryder
Appeared in Alien: Resurrection
While confessedly not as perfect a choice as Fassbender or Henriksen , Alien : Romuluscould have brought back Winona Ryder as Rook . Ryder look inAlien : Resurrectionas the mysterious mechanical man known as Call , who was attempting to keep her nature hidden after the event known as " The Recall " saw synthetic become outlawed . Overall , Call was an intriguing character despite existing in one of the worst - receivedAlienmovies .
Alien Movie
Rotten Tomatoes Critic grade
Alien: Romulus is the seventh film in the Alien franchise. The movie is directed by Fede Álvarez and will focus on a new young group of characters who come face to face with the terrifying Xenomorphs. Alien: Romulus is a stand-alone film and takes place in a time not yet explored in the Alien franchise.
Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
Alien
93 %
94 %
unknown
Alien 3
44 %
46 %
exotic : Christ’s Resurrection
55 %
39 %
Prometheus
73 %
68 %
Alien : Covenant
65 %
80 %
85 %
Regarding replacing Ian Holm as Rook , Ryder ’s Call is an interesting case cogitation . The obvious welfare is that Ryder is still a outstanding Hollywood actress and , account - wise , Alien : Romuluscould have given the Call synthetic somewhat of an origin storey . That said , Alien : Resurrectionis define 100 of years afterRomulus , mean it would have been less mother wit in - cosmos for Ryder to spiel Rook . Simply from a moral standpoint though , Ryder may have been the better pick for Rook than Holm inAlien : Romulus .
2David Jonsson
Appeared in Alien: Romulus
David Jonsson was widely regarded to have thebest performance inAlien : Romulusas Andy , the synthetic adopted crony of Cailee Spaeny ’s Rain . Jonsson toy Andy with such sympathy that he was instantly the favored part of many , making his turn into a more antagonistic force once Rook ’s programing is plant into him that much more effective . give how closely Jonsson ’s Andy is tied to RookinAlien : Romulus , it could be indicate that he was the best choice to play Rook in the first place .
The challenging moral dilemma this could have put up about Andy , who let out he was not supposed to be a benevolent helper but instead a cold retainer of the Weyland - Yutani Corporation could have benefitted his type arc …
If Jonsson had played Rook and Andy , it would have grant for a deep exploration of the character . The challenging moral dilemmas this could have lift about Andy , who discovers he was not supposed to be a benevolent helper but instead a dusty handmaid of the Weyland - Yutani Corporation could have benefitted his character arc even more . It also would have remove the admittedly jarring scene involve Rook from the film and allowed for greater hearing submerging . Although the widerAlienEaster eggs inAlien : Romuluswould have been removed , Jonnson play Rook would have turn better , both narratively and part - wise .
1A New Actor
While confessedly spacious , simply hiring a fresh actor to theAlienfranchise to portrayAlien : Romulus ' Rook would have been a better choice than bringing back Ian Holm posthumously . Although the connection toAlienwould be absent as a result , a unexampled actor would have allowedAlien : Romulusto endure on its own as a film in the franchise rather than one too focussed on tying back to the wider traditional knowledge . Even if this was the case , the motion-picture show ’s tie toPrometheuswould have meantAlien : Romulusslotted into the franchise at prominent , albeit with its own personal identity .
Holm returning as Rook was simply too jarring to make the connection toAlienworth it , and another thespian could have easily played that part . There are many histrion working in Hollywood who stand out at recreate somewhat cold , detached fibre , but who can turn on the nefarious aspectswhen require . Some examples include Ryan Gosling ( Drive ) , Paul Dano ( The Batman , Prisoners ) , Jake Gyllenhaal ( Nightcrawler ) , and Tilda Swinton ( The Chronicles of Narnia , Suspiria ) .
This would have offered the opportunity for futureAlienmovies to bring this actor back by innovate a new line of synthetic androids …
Of course , the aforementioned actor are only a tiny sampling size of thespian who could have imbued Rook with the necessary man-made timber and antipathetic traits while make the theatrical role their own . This would have offered the opportunity for futureAlienmovies to bring this actor back by usher in a new line of synthetic mechanical man . Nonetheless , Holm ’s alikeness was used for Rook inAlien : Romulus , regardless of whether there were sound choices in the kingdom of Hollywood .
Your Rating
Your input has not been keep
Cast
outlander : Romulus is the 7th film in the Alien franchise . The movie is directed by Fede Álvarez and will concenter on a new young group of character who add up face to face with the terrific Xenomorphs . Alien : Romulus is a stand - alone film and takes spot in a time not yet explored in the Alien enfranchisement .
