Criminal Minds
This article includes mentions of slaying , cannibalism , paedophilia , rape , and other horrific criminal offense .
Warning : this article contains SPOILERS forCriminal Minds . Years after the original serial ended , Criminal Mindsis still remember as one of the best criminal offence dramas of all meter , with undeniably the most terrifying killers to flush . The sequel , Criminal judgement : Evolution , has undertake to recreate the trick of the original , but even the most fearsome unknown subjects ( unsubs ) inEvolutionfail to hold a candle to the original serial . Evolution’sGold Star killers were interesting , but they blench in comparisonto many olderCriminal Mindsunsubs .
The fictionalizedBehavioral Analysis Unit inCriminal Mindsfaced C of culprit , ranging from disturbed but gentle - to - catch residential district members to high - visibility assassins who leave no track . The unambiguously troubling scoundrel were so memorable , that many are still waiting for a fittingalternative toCriminal Mindsto watch , and it ’s easy to empathize why . The original series put care into crafting naturalistic yet shocking fiber who could evoke fear , rage , disgust , et cetera with a single opening scene . While some unsubs had more screen time inCriminal Minds , some were terrorise enough to leave an impression with just one episode under their belt .
10Randall Garner AKA The Fisher King
Criminal Minds Season 1, Episode 22
The originalCriminal Mindsran for 15 seasons , but the procedural waste no time in creating menacing antagonists . The pilot season ofCriminal Mindsconcluded with the crimes of“The Fisher King”Randall Garner ( Charles Haid and Charley Rossman ) , a man who treat the investigation to rule him like a fantasy seeking . Garner set up enigma , leave convoluted clue and puzzles for the BAU to work out , and preserve his threat level by post Jason Gideon ( Mandy Patinkin ) a sever head and attacking Elle Greenaway ( Lola Glaudini ) .
What made The Fisher Billie Jean Moffitt King so frightening is his recklessness . AsCriminal Mindsseason 2 proved , Garner had no problem putting himself in harm ’s way for the saki of his schemes . His delusional seeking to deliver his dead daughter drove him mad , and anyone who got in the direction was just corroborative terms . Aside from kickstarting Elle ’s issue fromCriminal Minds , The Fisher King paved the way for more creative unsubs to keep an eye on .
9Benjamin Cyrus
Criminal Minds: Season 4, Episode 3
sure episode ofCriminal Mindsleft a terrifying legacy for their originality , but others uprise to popularity because of their realism . While long ton ofCriminal Mindsepisodes are based on existent cases , arguably one of the most well - known is “ Minimal Loss , ” instigate by the 1993 Waco siege . alike to real - life events , theCriminal Mindsepisode focalize on agents Spencer Reid ( Matthew Gray Gubler ) and Emily Prentiss ( Paget Brewster ) as they are entrance in the crossfire of a spiritual cult being raided .
While Will LaMontagne Jr. has been a key part of Criminal Minds for a prospicient time , actor Josh Stewart has tread aside from Criminal Minds : Evolution .
The episode ’s unsub , Benjamin Cyrus ( Luke Perry ) , may not have had dozens of victims from a murder spree to blow about , but his theatrical role was disturbing for a much round-eyed reason . Aside from leave the cult and manipulate home into agreeing to mass self-annihilation , Cyrus married and prang up a young teenagerwho ended up sacrifice her life to stop the BAU from ruining his program . The real repugnance of Benjamin Cyrus was his power to commit pedophilic actsand have a room full of people who believe it was God ’s will .
8John Curtis AKA The Replicator
Criminal Minds: Season 8, Episode 1
Criminal Mindsincluded so many memorable unsubs , one killer was able to cite distinct fabricated killers within Criminal Minds . John Curtis , aka“The Replicator”(Mark Hamill ) , not only replicated a unique modus operandi from the BAU ’s past ; Curtis also had inner data . After being contemn by his higher-ranking , Curtis made it his mission to get retaliation and taunt the FBI in the appendage with a cosmic string of imitator murders .
The only reason Curtis was able to cheer such elaborated crimes was because he was part of the organization that investigated them .
The Replicator seamlessly borrowed killing method from many different killers , which mechanically makes him one of the most unsettling unsubs inCriminal Minds . What made him sincerely terrifying was his connection to law enforcement . The only reason Curtis was able to reanimate such elaborate offense was because he was part of the organization that investigated them . John Curtis was one ofMark Hamill ’s best role , and he was doubtless the scariest .
7Pablo Vargas
Criminal Minds: Season 1, Episode 19
Sometimes , simplicity can be just as redoubtable as a grand spectacle killer whale . Pablo Vargas ( Alejandro Patiño ) was a two - pronged criminal : Vargas raped over a dozen womenbefore the BAU arrived in Mexico , and he then murdered his victim ’ mothers . part of Vargas were reminiscent of Alfred Hitchcock’sPsycho , like Vargas keeping the remains of his deceased mother in his living elbow room and donning dresses to attack cleaning woman .
Vargas left his victims shock by his intimate violation , buthe took their torture a stone’s throw further by murder their motherslong after the fact . While Pablo Vargas is a rare lawsuit of the BAU not apprehending a suspect , he was murdered vigilante - style by his own victims in clear karmic requital . That end may meet some , but the understated crimes of Vargas pack a shivery puncher , specially forCriminal Mindsseason 1 .
6Floyd Feylinn Ferell AKA Lucky
Criminal Minds: Season 3, Episode 8
Unsubs like The Replicator had full - season runs , but“Lucky”Floyd Feylinn Ferell ( Jamie Kennedy ) only need oneCriminal Mindsepisode to turn stomachs . Ferell spent most of his life in a psychiatric hospital after aim a bite out of his babe sister , but he was released when he turned 18 and free to build a life without restriction . After unfold a barbecue restaurant , Ferell began aim cleaning woman to kill and cannibalize them . To apologize his offence , Ferell insist he was possessed by a flesh - wipe out monster .
While the very conception of“Lucky”is nauseating , he blended in well enough to feed human remains to a lookup company without attracting notice . Ferell also feed human remains to customers at his eating house , deriving a nauseous pleasure from people unknowingly committing cannibalism . Criminal Mindshas many perturbing unsubs , but the sickening enactment of Floyd Feylinn Ferell suffer out in all the unsound ways .
5Samantha Malcom
Criminal Minds: Season 5, Episode 12
Samantha Malcom ( Jennifer Hasty ) is one of the saddestCriminal Mindsunsubs , due to her traumatic backstory . After the death of her female parent , Samantha ’s father begin hassle her and apologizing with dolls . Her Church Father also deal ECT therapy to secure Samantha would never severalise the authorisation about the ill-usage , fundamentally altering the chemistry of her genius . ThoughSamantha was only in her mid-20sat the time of her murder , it was obvious she had no lead to world .
Matthew Gray Gubler is most know for his theatrical role as Reid in Criminal Minds , but the actor will be on a show that might entail something young for Gubler .
Despite her trauma , what Samantha did to her victims was horrifying . After abducting women who resembled her dolls , Samantha would disable them with drug and flirt garb - up with their paralyzed bodies . Samantha essentially release her victims into living dolls , only switch them aside when their bodies succumbed to the immobilise drugs . Reid convinced Samantha to turn herself in by recovering her old dolls , turning “ The Uncanny Valley ” into one of the best but most unnervingReid - centricCriminal Mindsepisodes .
4Billy Flynn AKA The Prince Of Darkness
Criminal Minds: Season 5, Episode 23
Tim Curry ’s run asThe Prince Of Darkness inCriminal Mindswas spinal column - chilling for a mass of reasons . Billy Flynn worked as a Boogeyman , only killing under the natural covering of nighttime . Criminal Mindsset Flynn apart by add another terrifying aspect to his MO : Flynn would lead someone awake to see his crimes and live with the memory . Despite being a serial rapist and killer , Flynn managed to easily evade seizure for decades before the BAU lead the grammatical case .
Another horrible item from his Erolia minutilla onCriminal Mindswas that Flynn had been killing for so long , that he was able to target the household of his former witness , bringing his crimes full rotary . Tim Curry ’s masterful carrying out made his fictitious character petrifying , with Billy Flynn feeling like a nightmare come to aliveness . In the two - part“Prince of Darkness”special , Criminal Mindstook what drove of people fear most and turned it into a character with one C of victims .
3Roger & Anita Roycewood
Criminal Minds: Season 5, Episode 16
Undeniably one of the most memorable episodes ofCriminal Minds , “ Mosley Lane ” follows the slayer couple of Roger ( Bud Cort ) and Anita Roycewood ( Beth Grant).Together , the pair would abduct children and keep them captive in their home . The Roycewoods go forth families torn apart and consume by heartache , but the parents did n’t even experience the bad part of their child ’s abduction . As soon as one of their victims became too former or noncompliant , Anita would take them to the cellar and load them into a funeral crematorium .
Anita would burn the children while they were drugged , unconscious but still animated . From the inescapable pain of not knowing what happened to missing children to the annihilating revelation of the truth , “ Mosley Lane ” is an emotional rollercoaster and one ofMatthew Gray Gubler ’s greatest directed episode inCriminal Minds . “ Mosley Lane ” had one of the most deplorable killers and arguably the most heartbreaking line in the entire serial . When a father see his missing son was killed , but it was an impossible near - young woman , all he can ask is:“He was live yesterday ? ”
2Peter Lewis AKA Mr. Scratch
Criminal Minds: Season 10, Episode 21
Although multipleCriminal Mindscast member take off the seriesby the clock time Peter Lewis ( Bodhi Elfman ) was inclose , he was still a nightmare - induce character . Lewis was extremely levelheaded , and he even had a position at the NSA ( National Security Agency ) . Yet , Lewis was the last person concerned with anyone ’s safety . Criminal Mindshad many proxy killers , but none were as unsettling as Peter Lewis . Lewis would dose , mesmerize , and coerce people into murdering their own loved onesafter seeing“Mr . Scratch,”his alter ego .
Criminal Minds has had some dotty , unknown , and disturb unsubs and cases across its 17 seasons that have left watcher puzzled and unsettled .
Lewis was able to cause aggregative hysteria and death without ever wield the murder artillery , making him one of the most sinewy killer inCriminal Minds , despite being by proxy . The opinion of being drugged and realize you killed your family without having any control over your own mind is a nightmare scenario , but to Lewis it was just strategy . Using“Mr . Scratch,”Peter Lewis inflicted unimaginable pain on so many people .
1George Foyet AKA The Reaper
Criminal Minds: Season 4, Episode 18
Probably themost memorable unsub inCriminal Mindswas George Foyet ( C. Thomas Howell ) , known ominously as"The Reaper . “What made Foyet so terrific was n’t necessarily his brutal putting to death elan or even the number of dupe he had claimed . Rather , Foyet had a personal vendetta against SSA Aaron"Hotch"Hotchner ( Thomas Gibson ) and targeted him over multiple seasons . Foyet even terminate up kill Hotch ’s wife and nearly drink down his young son , but Hotch was at least able to salve his child in the tense 100th episode ofCriminal Minds .
Drawing divine guidance from many well - known serial cause of death , including The Zodiac , The Reaper was an dental amalgam of the worst people to ever live .
Of naturally , Foyet ’s fearsome presence as a standalone killer ca n’t be overlooked . pull back inspiration from many well - known serial killers , including The Zodiac , The Reaper was an amalgam of the worst people to ever live . Criminal Mindswas all about ripe inhibit wickedness , but Foyet ’s reign of terror turn up that evil can do a lot before it gets defeated . Though the sequel series is trying to step up its killer , nothing compares to the originalCriminal Mindsand the countless unsubs who leave behind a terrifying legacy .
SIGN UP NOW !
Your Rating
Your comment has not been saved
Cast
