Criminal Minds

The Behavioral Analysis Unit ( BAU ) inCriminal Mindshas deal with all manner of masterminds and unsubs , but Peter Lewis may be one of the most diabolical and terrifying they ’ve ever investigated . Criminal Mindsis a police force adjective that first ran for 15 season on CBS before ending in 2020 , but then it was revive for time of year 16 in November 2022 on Paramount Plus . The serial fall out the BAU , a peculiar division of the FBI , as they apply behavioral profiling and psychoanalysis proficiency to find the culprits , or unsubs ( unknown subjects ) , behind the United States ’ most grim and difficult crimes .

Over the trend of the show , the main cast ofCriminal Mindshas look into dozens of unsubs , from simple con artists all the means up to close genius - level serial sea wolf . While some crook were only of the “ scoundrel - of - the - calendar week ” variety , some like Peter Lewis were season - spanning foes who dug into the investigators as much the BAU labour into the unsubs . Peter Lewis , played by Bodhi Elfman , is one of these show - shaking villains . Lewis ’s arc across four seasons ofCriminal Mindsset him up against the BAU in a more personal way than almost any unsub had been before .

Related : Aaron Paul ’s Criminal Minds Role explicate

0326122_poster_w780.jpg

Peter Lewis Is The Mr. Scratch Killer In Criminal Minds

Peter Lewis first seem in season 10 , episode 21 , " Mr. Scratch " , which is considered one of thebest episodes ofCriminal Minds . The claim of the episode amount from how Lewis ’s victim see him when they are hallucinating . As a kid , Lewis live with his parents in a group home they run . A bad actor extend to Lewis ’s father being falsely incriminate of abuse toward the children , resulting in his murder in jail . After years of sour at the NSA , Lewis initiates his plan for retaliation against those who testified against his father in court . Lewis ’s formidable mathematical intellect is put to apply in his hunting for victim .

Lewis interject his dupe with a cocktail of drugs that make them hallucinatory and highly susceptible . He wedge some of them to kill their own loved I . Others , he get take their own lives . His M.O. is one of the more puzzling inCriminal Minds . Lewis finally captures BAU Agent Aaron " Hotch " Hotchner and drug him . Hotch resists and realize that Lewis himself show against his sire . Lewis ’s wave of violent death turns out to be a physique of internalized guilt . He does still negociate to make Hotch hallucinate vivid nightmare before he ’s captured , and that modest triumph is enough to satisfy the megalomaniacal Lewis before he is take into detainment .

Peter Lewis Became A Recurring Criminal Minds Character

After Peter Lewis is take into hands in time of year 10 ofCriminal Minds , he escape from prison in season 11 and becomes a sinister and incessant threat to the BAU and others in season 12 . Lewis alters his Modus Operandi around this prison term and begin target dupe with dissociative identity disorder to make them commit crimes and murders . The BAU soon realize that Lewis is once again commit offence , but find him becomes increasingly unmanageable . Throughout time of year 12 , Lewis arrest closer to the BAU until the two - part season finale ofCriminal Mindswhere he kill SSA Stephen Walker and drugs SSA Emily Prentiss .

Agents Luke Alvez and Spencer Reid have a shootout that finally ends in Lewis falling to his death from the ceiling . Lewis ’s electric discharge showed how despite all the open and honest citizenry working in the BAU , a felon of enough cunning and evil can see even their own people put in danger . Hotch is forced to leave the BAU in fear for his confrere and Reid is particularly affect by the upshot of time of year 12 and take in he wanted to kill Lewis at the end , a feeling that trouble him going forward . Lewis ’s violent and helter-skelter actions left a more long-lived mark than almost any of the othermemorable unsubs onCriminal Minds .

Peter Lewis (Bodhi Elfman) talking to Hotch in Criminal Minds

A drawing of Mr. Scratch in Criminal Minds.

Hallucination of Mr Scratch in Criminal Minds.

Criminal Minds