Doctor Who
Doctor Who ’s late big reveal has exit some healthy secret plan gob in the telecasting show ’s foresightful canon . The Timeless Child mystery has been in effect since Jodie Whittaker ’s first few episodes , reemerging at the first of time of year 12 , but only now has a classical response been offered . In " The Timeless Children , " The Master break that the Time Lords originated when The Doctor fell through a boundary from another universe into our own . The natives of Gallifrey used the inherent healing ability of The Doctor to create the positive feedback caper they would later ramp up a civilization upon , but due to some transaction with The Divison , Doctor Who ’s Hero of Alexandria was forced to forget this history and their importance to Gallifrey ’s origination .
Such a seismic alteration toDoctor Whocanon has obviously split fan feeling , but while it might be too early to recite whether theTimeless Childis a stroke of genius or a lesson in how to destroy a franchise in 65 minute of arc , it ’s hard to argue that the idea is n’t wholly ridiculous , one way or the other . To completely turn 50 years of story on its head is a brave and insane project and , ironically , only time will prescribe whether this dotty idea will pay off .
Related : Doctor Who Season 12 Keeps rip Off Old ( & Better ) Villains
As one might gestate , this rewriting ofDoctor Whohistoryhas created some plot holes where the new story does n’t quite match up with what fan already be intimate . The conform to points may yet be come up to inDoctor Who ’s futurity , and some are more of import than others , but as things stomach , they are narrative gaps that the Timeless Child secret has created . Here are all theDoctor Whoplot gob time of year 12 ’s last left behind .
The Blue Box TARDIS
Perhaps the most dazzling issue with The Doctor having go amount of past life beforeWilliam Hartnellconcerns the blue loge form of the TARDIS . After learning that she ’s far , far aged than she think she is , Jodie Whittaker ’s Doctor surmise that the Ruth Doctor encountered previously must be a harbinger date stamp beyond her ( supposedly ) first incarnation . Certainly , this would explain why Ruth says she ’s working for someone ( The Division ) and why she does n’t acknowledge the Sonic Screwdriver or the Thirteenth Doctor . But Ruth ’s TARDIS is shaped like a constabulary box seat , and this should n’t be the case if she amount before Hartnell .
InDoctor Who ’s 2nd - ever installment , the First Doctor travels from sixties England to the prehistorical epoch , and upon exiting the TARDIS , is surprised to see that his chamaeleon circuit has n’t changed the ship ’s exterior from a police box to something more period - appropriate . This is the moment the TARDIS accept ( and keeps ) its police box range , so Ruth ’s TARDIS should still be camouflaging as mean .
Two Hearts
In " The Timeless Children , " it ’s let out that the people of Gallifrey used The Doctor , a child from another worldly concern , to obtain powers of positive feedback , unnaturally stealing the youngster ’s natural abilities . However , this does n’t automatically excuse why the rest of The Doctor ’s biology is the same as every otherTime Lord , especially when it number to having two hearts . So are The Doctor’srealrace and the Time Lords both coincidentally bear with dual tickers , or did the Gallifreyans originally have one heart , but Tecteun ’s experiments resulted in the Time Lords developing a second over clock time , mimic the Doctor ’s physiology ? Certainly , there ’s no reference of ancient Time Lords only possessing a exclusive heart .
On another biological eminence , Paul McGann ’s Eighth Doctor claim to be half - human . While this was arguablyalreadya plot hole , the fortune of The Doctor take human deoxyribonucleic acid are now even more unlikely , since she does n’t even come from this universe .
Related : Why Doctor Who Wo n’t OFFICIALLY Confirm Jack Harkness Is The Face of Boe
The “Doctor” Name
Similar to the TARDIS plot golf hole mentioned above , the name " The MD " is something that should be unique tothisincarnation of the character . In " The Sound of Drums,“The Master sound out he remembers The Doctorchoosing his own title because he wanted to " make mass better . " Logically , then , all of the pre - Hartnell MD should call themselves something totally unlike , but Ruth once again confute this by also referring to herself as " The Doctor of the Church . " An ineluctable katzenjammer from a late living , perhaps ?
Although not a secret plan yap in itself , it ’s also interesting that The Doctor’srealname now holds either far less or far more significance . The Matt Smith era teased , but never break , the birth name of The Doctor , which is known only to the Time Lords andRiver Song . If The Doctor ’s name comes from the character ’s true dwelling house satellite , this could be a lively cue as to their descent . However , if The Doctor ’s mysterious real name was just one given by Tecteun , it means virtually nothing now .
Why Does The Doctor Have Only 12 Regenerations?
" The Timeless Children " explains that the Time Lords harvested The physician ’s positive feedback ability for their own role , but strictly specify its usage to 12 time , so as to avoid create immortals . But if the regeneration limit is ego - levy , it should n’t implement to The Doctor at all . As the Timeless Child , it ’s impossible to say how often The Doctor can renew , but until specified otherwise , it ’s natural to assume she could do so indefinitely , which meansMatt Smith ’s Doctordidn’t necessitate a new re-formation cycle in parliamentary law to switch into Peter Capaldi . Did the Time Lordspretendto give The Doctor a young set of lives just to maintain their illusion , or did Tecteun come up a manner to visit the Time Lords ' own demarcation on The Doctor herself ?
Regenerating Into A Child
The Doctor remembers growing up as a child , and these memory board are support by The Master , who claims that her entire least sandpiper with The Division happenedbeforethe duo develop up together on Gallifrey . WhileDoctor Whoseason 12shows viewers how The Division efface The Doctor ’s memories of her earlier lives , it ’s not clear how she went back to being a child . Traditionally , Time Lords age from young to maturity , but the re-formation process does n’t touch this , instead just renewing the adult physical structure . This is demonstrated in " The Timeless Children " itself , when the Timeless Child falls from a cliff and regenerates into another fry . A collage then shows the various incarnation of the type getting old and older , and even a novel re-formation cycle does n’t readjust the aging process . Consequently , The Doctor should n’t remember being a child at all .
Related : Doctor Who : All The clue To The Ruth / New Doctor Twist
River Song
River Song ’s origins were already convoluted , but are even more baffling now with the Timeless Child in play . The account goes that the Eleventh Doctor ’s companion , Amy and Rory , had sexual urge on the TARDIS while move around through the Time Vortex and their shaver , while still human , was invest with regeneration abilities . When it was think that the Time Lords had master re-formation on their own accord , this was just about plausible , but does n’t quite work neatly alongside the season 12 conclusion ’s reveals . If regeneration is something the Time Lords genetically engineered from The Doctor ’s unsung subspecies , Rory being unable to keep his transonic screwdriver in check should n’t have meant his kid was indue the same power .
The Doctor Entered The Matrix Before
The Master claims to have accidentally uncovered the secret of the Timeless Child while stab around in the Matrix , but this might be consider strange , as both he and The Doctor have nose around in there before . Tom Baker ’s Doctor and the disfigured Master entered the Matrix in " The Deadly Assassin , " with the Fourth Doctor going back for more in " The Invasion of Time , " wearing a crown that provide unrestricted access to the jumbo Gallifreyan hard effort . SinceThe Masteralmost seemed to stumble across The Doctor ’s root story , why did neither fiber point out it before ? The potential account here is that the Matrix is so vast , The Doctor and Master were both fool by the Brendan sensing filter while search the amassed datum previously .
The Valeyard
The Valeyard was introduced during the Sixth doc ’s reign as an merger of The Doctor ’s darker instincts converge into one being , aver to egress at some point after the twelfth positive feedback . When Peter Capaldi ’s sovereignty lead off , Doctor Whofans swiftly began to speculate whether The Valeyard would now make their long - expect show , but only a abbreviated reference was offered bySteven Moffatduring this re-formation . Now fans know that The Doctoractuallypassed 12 regenerations long , long ago , The Valeyard ’s absence looks even stranger .
Where Do The Division Go?
There remain much closed book skirt The Division . The shadowed crowd look to be a undercover offshoot of Time Lords that actively meddle with meter , in contradiction of Gallifrey ’s common computer code , and The Doctor conducted missions for them before pass out in a stolen TARDIS . However , the existence of The Division produce a plot maw when considering the occasion Time Lordshaveelected to fiddle with history and recruited The Doctor to do so . Ever since the time of the Third Doctor , the Time Lords have sporadically portion The Doctor commission , such as wiping out theDaleksin the classic " generation of the Daleks . " This was most likely at the behest of the Celestial Intervention Agency ( another shadowy Time Lord outfit ) but if The Division existed , would n’t this be their area of expertness ? This unexampled group appear to just be doing precisely what the Time Lords have been for years already .
relate : physician Who Season 12 ’s Darker Doctor Is A Big Improvement
Clara Entering The Doctor’s Time Stream
In Matt Smith ’s " The Name of the Doctor " time of year 7 conclusion , The Great Intelligence enter The Doctor ’s prison term stream to loosen all the goodDoctor Who ’s hero had ever achieve in the past , with Clara bravely jumping in to contain him . This clip current harbour the intact past , present and future of The Doctor and Clara get all of it , even reveal the previously - unobserved War Doctor as a result of bump everything Doctor - related lay out in front of her . Surely , she would ’ve seen the pre - Hartnell Doctors during this experience ? Clara knew enough of The Doctor ’s origin to lead him towards the right TARDIS , so there ’s no reason for her not to go further back beyond that . Is this something The Division could have even meddle with ?
More : What To Expect From Doctor Who Season 13
Doctor Whoreturns at Christmastime with " Revolution of the Daleks " on BBC and BBC America .
