Related
Eiichiro Oda’sOne Piecemight be one of the greatest gum anime ever to grace the small cover , but it is not without its flaws . While its swaggering action , treasure - search adventures , and iconic plagiarizer archetype render all the element of the " classic pirate tale " that has capture audiences for ages , there are notable issues that can make it intriguing — especially for newbie — to fully immerse themselves in the story .
There are rough-cut problems that plague long - established gum anime franchises , such as trying to wrap one ’s head around their deep and complex lore or image out how to “ catch up ” on a serial publication with over 1,100 episode . as luck would have it , there are ways to whelm these barrier , like consulting fan sites and anime news hubs to help make for you up to upper . However , the main offspring withOne Pieceruns mystifying than that . It strikes at the very core of the story — its supporter . but put , Luffy is just boring .
The Relentless Pursuit of Becoming the Pirate King Makes One Piece A Tedious Narrative
With One Resounding Goal That Never Changes
To elucidate , I ’m not suggesting that Luffy is a bad primary character — he is n’t . However , he lacks profundity and flunk to stand out as a dynamic or compelling protagonist . In other words , he comes across as one - dimensional and uninteresting , peculiarly when compared to other characters inOne Pieceor to protagonists in the broader gum anime landscape . The issue is worsen by Luffy ’s status as the franchise ’s iconic face for over 25 years , making his limitations more obtrusive .
ab initio , Luffy ’s destination of becoming the Pirate Kingwas captivating and provided a steady narrative yarn amidst the serial ' frequent detours . However , his steadfast fixation on this dream decades later suggests that his face-off , travel and experiences have had small impact on his case . His unassailable decision , while admirable , render him imperviable to transformative growth . While this might be acceptable for a petty grapheme , a independent character ’s unfitness to acquire or undergo meaning growing make them stable - and the history - slow .
Ace ’s death sent shockwaves throughout the community and alter the future tense of the series forever .
Luffy ’s lack of growth precipitously contrasts withhis crewmate Nico Robin ’s ontogeny . As the sole survivor of the World Government ’s genocidal secret plan against Ohara , Robin is initially presented as a cold and calculating somebody , weight by cryptical self - doubt . However , after link up the Straw Hat Pirates , specially following the " Enies Lobby Arc , " she learns to trust others and squeeze her own worth . This transformation solidified her theatrical role as a all-important member of the crew , and arguably , positions her as the case-by-case best equipped to assist Luffy in reach his ambition .
This is not to say that Luffy undergo no growth . He does learn to effective control and heighten his Devil Fruit ability , and he clearly becomes a more effected pirate as the series progresses . However , there is small , if any , significant phylogeny in his goals , personality , or worldview . For example , while Luffy experiences vivid despair whenAce dies at Marineford , he is not consume by ire or a desire for revenge . or else , his grief fuel a renewed determination to become stronger , reduce his vulnerabilities , and protect those closemouthed to him . While this reaction is understandable , given how close Luffy and Ace were , the fact that Ace sacrificed himself to save Luffy — it ultimately feel underwhelming .
Luffy Is Such A Good Guy That It’s Bad For The Story
There Are Few If Any Flaws To His Character
The less piquant aspect of Luffy ’s unmarried - mindedness in becoming the Pirate King might have been mitigated if he possessed a more complex or nuanced personality . alternatively , Luffy is present as one of the most solid , straightforward , simple , and uncontroversial character in all gum anime . He ’s a really nice guy who is rarely judgmental and consistently tolerant of mass ’s differences . It was Luffy , after all , who insist that the crewtake on Brook , the nine - foot - grandiloquent skeleton in the cupboard . Luffy thrives on the chill of escapade and the freedom it work . He is also fiercely loyal to his friends and comrades . doubtless , Luffy typify the definition of " a stand - up guy wire . "
While Luffy ’s carefree and optimistic personality make him a lovable companion , mate , or leader , it does n’t translate well to a compelling main persona in a pirate risky venture story or shōnen Zanzibar copal series . His simplistic " protect my supporter , follow my dreams , and have fun " mantra , though endearing , preclude the depth and nuance expect of a protagonist . Traditional pirate tales feature complex characters with multifaceted personality , ponder the moral ambiguities of being both feared and admire . In contrast , Luffy is rarely prompted – by himself or others – to introspect or present the consequence of his natural process .
One Piece is so long that it is bound of have game holes and inconsistencies , but this plot of ground jam involving Sabo and Ace needs answers .
Conversely , anime is filled with protagonists who deal with complex site , moral dilemmas , and interior conflicts . Take , for good example , Tokyo Ghoul ’s Ken Kaneki , who wrestled — almost daily — with his ghoulish indigence to ware human flesh and his human disgust at the idea of eating other the great unwashed . Then there’sChainsaw Man ’s Denji , whose desire for a unspoilt life systematically clashes with order ’s outlook for the Chainsaw Man to “ do the good thing . ” In both cases , the tension experienced by Ken and Denji create their stories more compelling and engaging . But none of that is there with Luffy .
Luffy Lacks the Finesse Of Other Shōnen Protagonists
Still Missing Major Emotional Development
Another unfortunate aspect of Luffy ’s consistent and unproblematic personality is his predictability . disregardless of the position — whether it ’s the loss of his bunch in the " Sabaody Archipelago Arc " or Nami ’s agony in Arlong Park — fans intuitively have a go at it how Luffy will react . He will express sadness , vow to become strong , promise to do well and fight ferociously for his ally and crewmates . Ultimately , he will continue his seeking to achieve his dream , never compromise his core values .
Luffy ’s function as a static , inspirational figure fit well within the world ofOne Piece , but it also means he does n’t undergo the variety of transformative ontogenesis that adds profoundness and dazzle to a quality .
Of course , these are not regretful values to uphold . However , the predictability of Luffy ’s reactions removes any element of surprise , story tension , or aroused impact . As a result , scenes that should be powerfully moving instead feel dusty , formulaic , and unrelatable , making it harder for the audience to link up emotionally at the second they should . It also put forward an unintended question — why ca n’t Luffy evolve like other characters in the tale ?
While Luffy ’s unwavering decision , loyalty , and charisma make him a compelling and iconic type , his lack of substantial development , inner engagement , and nuanced personality can make him feel less piquant compare to other shōnen protagonists . His persona as a static , inspirational chassis fits well within the world ofOne Piece , but it also means he does n’t undergo the variety of transformative maturation that tot up depth and dazzle to a type . As a witness seeking a more intricate and develop main character , I discover Luffy ’s simplistic personality to be quite disappointing , which ultimately has led toOne Piecebeing a rather " meh " experience for me .
Custom Image by Merlyn De Souza
