It ’s becoming clear to me that the entireMarried at First Sightcasting strategy needs to change , and there are signs this is happen . get hitched with at First Sightdebuted on Lifetime in 2014 , and showcased a control panel of three expert matchmaking and counseling three couples who got married to strangers . Over the years , the data formatting and style of the show have changed , and the franchise now has 18 complete season behind it . Since time of year 10 , five couple have been matched by the experts , but the experimentation ’s eight - week - tenacious length has n’t commute . TheMAFSexperts have also changed .

Dr. Pepper Schwartzhas been with the show since time of year 1 , whilePastor Cal Robersonjoined in season 4 , and Dr. Pia Holec was added in time of year 15 . The other large format alteration has come through the amount the duo interact . In the earlier time of year , the couples did n’t comingle , whereas now , the five pairs all go on the honeymoon together , live in the same building , and do different group get - togethers , making the drama promote . Moreover , there have beenmany loser over the years , particularly with molding , butI am feeling positive about the coming changesbeing made in that respect .

How Does MAFS Cast People?

Scouting

get married at First Sighthas been a pioneering show in the world TV industry , and I see that it ’s continuing to get its legs . In 2025 , it was announced thatMAFSwould be move from its longsighted - time home on Lifetime , over to Peacock , a rain buckets monster whose largest rival is Netflix . While with Lifetime , I ’ve learned that the franchise casting scheme has not given way to many magnetic , telegenic , emotionally usable and well-informed mold penis , as the experiment calls for .

MAFS ' casting strategy involves a mixing of tactic . Married at First Sighttravels to different metropolis each season to host the experiment . Some city , like Chicago , Boston , and New York , have had several seasons hosting the show . As the show targets a urban center , the program admissions become open , and singles from the city are invited to apply online . However , I ’ve hail to find out thatthe issue of applicant has dwindled over the years , leaving not a bombastic enough pool of practicable applicant to proceed .

The second and last strategy thatMAFSemploys to find cast members , is that production scouts citizenry on dating apps or Instagram within the urban center the show will be hosted in . Once production identifies citizenry who they think would be honorable for the show , product set about them with the prompt to apply .

Married at First Sight experts Pastor Cal & Dr. Pepper & season 19 cast Jalyn & Patric in side by side images

Custom Image By César García

I am convinced this is not the best drill , as it leaves a lot of way for scout people to have clout - chamfer intention , be unfit for marriage at whatever stage they are in , or be unfamiliar with the show and what it ’s trying to reach .

On a large platform like Peacock , I trust more constitutive casting will become easier , as the road to give is more accessible just because it ’s more well - known . I see that this will give style to more applications without the demand for heavy scouting . MAFSscouting casting maneuver rub me the wrong way , as several notable co - opted cast have contributed tothe show ’s misfortunate success rate of only 19%of the full dyad jibe still being together .

MAFS Has Cast Many Problematic Participants

Too Many Clout Chasers & Emotionally Unintelligent Cast

Since I ’ve draft theMAFScasting strategy , I palpate it important to showcasethe elusive nature of some of the plaster cast who were scouted . MAFSseason 14 in Boston dramatis personae phallus , Alyssa Ellman , said she never applied , but was scouted . I watched her believe that the experiment was curated for her , as she thought the expert were going to deliver her her perfect , ideal man , without any compromise . When she espouse Chris Collette , she ended her wedding in bust , unwilling to be in the same way with him , as he was n’t what she ask for physically .

Alyssa even remarked that she was"robbed"of the experience , which I feel underscores her green attitude misapprehension of the cognitive process . InMAFSseason 18 , both David Trimble and Madison Myers were recruited by production , and they were involved with the biggest scandal inMAFShistory . They carried on an intimacy from the honeymoon , and only ditched their original spouses in favour of dating one another when the time of year was about over . I thinkthese examples spotlight the booby trap of recruitment , as these types of cast were never appropriate choices for the show and man and wife .

MAFS Could Cast People Like The Golden Bachelor & Bachelorette Franchise

Friends & Family Nominations

I ’m certain thatMarried at First Sightneeds to overhaul their casting strategy to fend off casting the wrong hoi polloi . And I feel they should take a Sir Frederick Handley Page fromThe Golden BachelorandThe Golden Bachelorette ’s Quran , which is tohave people constitute their friend , class fellow member , or co - doer for the show . This is an interesting cast slant that has proved incontrovertible in term of draw quality for both ABC shows , andMAFScould benefit from open up up their casting scheme to a bodily structure like that .

Reality goggle box is more democratic than ever . With so many to opt from , here are some of the best reality telly present to pullulate or see the right way now .

MAFS Is Casting An Older Demographic

Which Is The Biggest Change

Married at First Sighthas also always ramble a certain unseasoned demographic of multitude . In time of year 16 , 25 - year - old Domynique Kloss was cast , and she proclaimed that she was an old soulfulness with maturity beyond her geezerhood , and that proved to be completely awry . She asked for a divorcement from Mackinley Gilbert upon hark back from the honeymoon , after believing he was n’t as adventuresome as she was . She did n’t give him or the process a chance , showcasing her unfit nature for the show .

Most cast members have been in their mid - to belated twenties , with only a handful being in their mid - late 30 .

Season 18 turned a Sir Frederick Handley Page , however , with Thomas McDonald being 42 , and Ikechi Ojoré being 41 . I guess this move towards an elder demographic is positive , as more veteran adults could make better partners . I am excited that this trend towards less ageism and more cellular inclusion will become a new staple fiber ofMarried at First Sight(via@mafsfan ) , asseason 19 will have a distich in their late - forties / early fifties , and one in their previous 50 / former sixties . I see these casting choices as firm proof the show ’s casting is head up in a raw way , and I ’m here for the change .

the golden bachelorette cast, with men gathered around in casual clothes

Source:@mafsfan / Instagram

Your Rating

Your comment has not been saved

Cast

jasmine alan cumming

Married at First Sight Season 17 poster

Cast Placeholder Image

Reality TV

Married At First Sight