The Alto Knights
Robert De Niro ’s new gangster movieThe Alto Knightsis pull together attention specifically for the player ’s twofold role as both of its friend . Thefilm star De Niroas two crime bosses , Vito Genovese and Frank Costello , very often let the cat out of the bag to each other in the same crack . While it ’s skilfully conduct by Barry Levinson and the proficient squad behind him , it ’s grueling not to feel that those ask in the project have go out of their way of life to throw De Niro twice , a move that come across as a cinematic gimmick that detracts from other aspects of the movie .
Indeed , The Alto Knights ’s Rotten Tomatoes scoreshows it has divided critics and audiences , receiving assorted review precisely for the unnecessary effort it exerts clone Robert De Niro into several setting . As many critic have take down , surelythere are other worker of comparable experience and playing chopswho could have taken one of these two tip roles of De Niro ’s work force . He may be one of the criminal offence genre ’s gravid - ever actors , but wad of prospect are available who would have offered a more compelling matchup when it came tocastingThe Alto Knightsthan De Niro talking to himself .
5Armand Assante
As Vito Genovese
Armand Assante has quite the crime genre résumé , having become a mob gaffer medical specialist following his Golden Globe - nominate portrayal of Puerto Rican drug kingpin Bobby Tex in the 1990 movieQ & A. His two most celebrated public presentation are the title function of John Gotti in HBO ’s 1996 TV movieGotti , which won him an Emmy Award , and his depiction of Dominic Gattano inRidley Scott’sAmerican Gangsteralongside Denzel Washington .
In 1992 , Armand Assante star as Carl " Dally " D’Allesandro in the offence biopicHoffa , which covers standardised ground to Martin Scorsese ’s Robert De Niro movieThe Irishman , but from the perspective of union political boss Jimmy Hoffa .
Having spent the past 18 geezerhood since the latter role play in low - budget flick and movies made outside of the United States , Assante appear to be out of favour in Hollywood , with most studio likely of the opinion that his good days are behind him . But he has six days on Robert De Niro , andhis acclaimed oeuvre impersonate some of New York ’s most infamous crime bossessuggests that he ’d make a more than convincing Vito Genovese .
4David Proval
As Frank Costello
Robert De Niro and David Proval go way back , having both star in Martin Scorsese ’s early masterpieceMean Streetsat the start of their calling . Since then , their vocation have taken very different trajectories , but both have circled back to their starting point in the criminal offence genre . It take Proval a small longer to get there than De Niro , but his underrated performance asRichie Aprile fromThe Sopranosdemonstrates that playing a gangster is what he does comfortably .
Besides this role , Proval has had a distinguished career in both film and telly , with parts inThe Shawshank RedemptionandEverybody Loves Raymondamong the highlights . Proval ’s most late role was as a rout bossin Cameron Van Hoy ’s 2021 crime thrillerFlinch , proving that he ’s still got the chops to go toe - to - toe with the likes of his old costar De Niro . Proval ’s hard - talking , rugged - guy rope role would make the everlasting Frank Costello to De Niro ’s more quietly - address Vito Genovese .
3Harvey Keitel
Harvey Keitel is anotherMean Streetscast member who would have excelled in a head - to - head with Robert De Niro inThe Alto Knights . Of naturally , Keitel require no introduction . His work opposite De Niro both in Martin Scorsese ’s 1973 criminal offense classic and in arguablyScorsese ’s best movieof all , Taxi Driver , would be enough to characterise him for a lead role in Levinson ’s unexampled moving-picture show on its own . fox in Keitel ’s role inThe Irishmanand Brian De Palma’sWiseguys , and he ’s perhaps overqualified if anything .
Although he ’s now 85 years honest-to-goodness , Harvey Keitel is still as productive as ever , do one activeness movie after another , with three more currently in the line . He likely would have jumped at the chance to act opposite his sometime friend De Niro again , andhis physical likeness to Vito Genovesewould have meantThe Alto Knightsmakeup department could have carry through some of their prosthetics budget .
2Andy Garcia
In the quad of three yr , via two of thebest crime picture at the end of the 1980s , Andy Garcia blend from a piece - part actor to one of the frontmost stars of the criminal offense literary genre . While he ’s generally avoided being typecast since his roles inThe UntouchablesandThe Godfather Part III , he ’s still primed and ready to play a mobster whenever call upon , as his roles in 2014’sRob the Mob , Clint Eastwood ’s 2018 offence movieThe Mule , and recent Paramount+ drama seriesLandmandemonstrate .
Although he ’s in reality of Cuban descent , Andy Garcia has play Italian or Italian - American characters on eight dissimilar occasions throughout his career .
Garcia is one of the few doer out there today from a younger generation than De Niro ’s who could matchthe actor ’s intimidating onscreen comportment while he ’s play a mafioso . As with Keitel , a twosome of Vito Genovese ’s signature spectacle and Andy Garcia would be an excellent likeness for the real - life mafia don .
Custom image by Simone Ashmoore
1Al Pacino
As Frank Costello Or Vito Genovese
Thanks to Martin Scorsese’sThe Irishman , we ’ve now seen New Hollywood ’s two most fabled actors , Al Pacino and Robert De Niro , face off in two dissimilar movies . Pacino and De Niro ’s first onscreen merging inHeathad acquired an almost mythical status by the time Frank Sheeran met Jimmy Hoffa in Scorsese ’s slowly - burning Netflix criminal offense epical . The Alto Knightscould have throw us one last fortune to see these titans of Italian - American movie theatre go head - to - head .
Al Pacino and Robert De Niro are two of the greatest actors of all clip , and here are their movie collaboration ranked from bad to best .
De Niro and Pacino are even closer in age than Vito Genovese and Frank Costello , and both actors are equipped to play near any gangster role put in front of them , cast from their respective parts in theGodfathertrilogyto De Niro ’s comic turn inAnalyze This , and Pacino ’s equally unexpended - field portrayal “ Big Boy Caprice ” inDick Tracy . These two cinema legends could be allow to sort out who would dally whom inThe Alto Knightsamongst themselves , with Pacino a near - double-dyed fit for either Costello or Genovese .
Your Rating
Your input has not been saved
Cast
