Related
The supporter ofThe Lord of the Ringstrilogy , Frodo Baggins , is one of the most unforgettable heroes within the phantasy canon . J.R.R. Tolkien , the author of the epic Bible and the prequel , The Hobbit , created both Frodo and his sometime first cousin , Bilbo , as two of the most substantial ring bearers of the series . WhileFrodo is known for taking the One Ring all the way to Mount Doomto destroy , Bilbo never embarked on a journeying of this scale . However , it ’s undeniable that Bilbo was n’t seduced by the Ring the mode other characters were .
There are many reasons whythe Ring affected Bilbo otherwise than Frodo inLord of the Rings , so it ’s interesting to question whether Bilbo would ’ve been open of shoulder the burden Frodo did . If Bilbo had hail into contact with the Ring and been the one who volitionally sham the responsibility of taking the hoop to its destruction , it ’s wholly potential that he would have made it all the style , as he has a pure nub . However , the external factors that made Frodo ’s journey so strenuous might have been too much for Bilbo .
Bilbo Shows Great Restraint With The One Ring, But He Might Not Have Under Frodo’s Circumstances
The period when Frodo had the Ring was much more strenuous than Bilbo’s time
When Frodo comes into possession of the One Ring , it ’s when Sauron is gaining strength , almost back at full power , and the Ring awakens from its hibernating geological period . This , combined with the fact that Frodo was actively bringing the doughnut to Mount Doom to destruct it , make his experience with the Ring vastly different from Bilbo ’s . It ’s incredible that Bilbo was n’t taint by the Ring as Gollum was , as he had it for plenty of metre , but Bilbo still had cryptic ties to the Shire , and Sauron was n’t back when he found the Ring .
AsLord of the Ringprogresses , we see Frodo get progressively attach to the Ring and contend to resist its temptation .
The fact thatBilbo resisted the One Ring inLord of the Ringsand willingly establish up the Ring after possessing it for age is an indicator of his strong suit . However , this was during a time period of peace when the Ring was bidding its time and not actively trying to return to Sauron . AsLord of the Ringprogresses , we see Frodo get more and more attached to the Ring and shinny to protest its temptation . However , the Ring was working much firmly to own Frodo and control him at this pointedness .
motion-picture show
Rotten Tomatoes Critic musical score
Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score
The Fellowship of the Ring ( 2001 )
91 %
95 %
The Two Towers ( 2002 )
The Return of the King ( 2003 )
94 %
Custom Image by Yeider Chacon
86 %
The Hobbit Proved Bilbo Could Handle An Adventure Like The One In Lord Of The Rings
Bilbo is just as resourceful and brave as Frodo
Of course , it ’s because Bilbo first lead the shire horse and decided to have an risky venture that the issue ofLord of the Ringsunfold , and that Frodo feels he can venture out on his own as well . It ’s because Frodo idolizes Bilbo and sees that Hobbits can leave the shire horse that he ’s empower to help Gandalf and actualise he ’s the only person who can pack the burden of the Ring . The Lord of the Ringsis much more vivid and vehement thanThe Hobbit . However , Bilbo confront down a tartar and should n’t be underestimated .
Bilbo was around Frodo ’s years when he went on his dangerous undertaking , and he retrieve friendship and companionship with the dwarves he get together , entail he would ’ve easily fit into the Fellowship . However , The Hobbitbook is much less natural action - jam than the motion-picture show adaptations , and Bilbo does n’t face up as much high - stake danger as Frodo . The Lord of the Ringsmovies have more natural action thanThe Hobbitmovies , and Frodo comes nerve to face with many terrific creatures . Though , it ’s potential that Bilbo would show just as much bravery in his shoes .
An Unexpected Journey ( 2012 )
64 %
83 %
The Desolation of Smaug ( 2013 )
74 %
85 %
The Battle of the Five Armies ( 2014 )
59 %
Gollum Would Have Complicated Things For Bilbo’s Journey With The One Ring
It’s unlikely that Bilbo and Gollum would’ve been able to make peace
Gollum is one of the most complex and interesting characters inLord of the Rings , as he ’s conflicted by the centuries of corruption by the Ring and the kindness Frodo show him . In some ways , Gollum is simply help Frodo and Sam get to Mount Doom to betray them and ultimately take the Ring for himself , buthe does feel an fastening to Frodo that he never would ’ve with Bilbo . The confrontation in the cave between Bilbo and Gollum would ’ve made any human relationship impossible .
Peter Jackson ’s Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit trilogies be one of cinema ’s most famous franchise , but how does each mediate - earth movie social rank ?
If Bilbo had been the one to carry the band to Mount Doom , Gollum would ’ve killed him the first chance he got . rather of helping Bilbo and finally being the one to fill in the Ring ’s journey of destruction , Gollum would ’ve been a consistent roadblock for Bilbo . It ’s possible that Bilbo would have simply toss off Gollum and die on with his journeying , but the fact that he initially testify mercifulness proves that Bilbo does have an inherently kind heart and would n’t need to do this , precede to later number .
There’s Another Thing Frodo Had Going For Him In LOTR That Bilbo Didn’t
Frodo wasn’t alone in his journey
Frodo is never alone in his journey to destroy the Ring . Even after he leaves the Fellowship , Sam stays with Frodo until the death , and it ’s undeniable that Frodo could n’t have completed his task without Sam . to boot , even if Merry and Pippin are sometimes more of a nuance than a help , their personal connections to Frodo help propel him , and they impart in other ways as the narrative continues . Unlike Frodo , Bilbo did n’t have these kinds of friend and thick personal connections to other Hobbits .
Characters far stronger than Sam were allure by Sauron ’s One Ring in The Lord of the Rings , but the blue Hobbit was more insubordinate than anyone .
Though he loved the Shire , Bilbo did n’t have the kind of friends that Frodo did , and this piece of the narrative ca n’t be overlooked . Without Sam , Merry , and Pippin , Frodo belike would ’ve been bogged down by the pressure of stock the Ring and would ’ve lost good deal of why he was so determined to demolish it . Though Bilbo made acquaintance on his own escapade , they were n’t from the Shireand did n’t portion out the story and chemistry that Frodo had with his friend .
Bilbo Baggins Would Not Have Been Able To Destroy The One Ring Like Frodo
He wouldn’t have made it to Mount Doom like Frodo does
Bilbo Baggins would n’t have been capable to ruin the One Ring as Frodo did inLord of the Rings . While it ’s honest that Frodo himself create the ill-timed alternative in the end and is n’t resistant to the puff of the Ring , I do n’t think Bilbo would ’ve made it that far to begin with . The cause the Ring has such a difficult time swaying Frodo and finding something to pull strings him with is becausethe thing Frodo wants most is to destroy the Ring . Since the Ring utilise people ’s deepest desire to use them , it struggles with Frodo .
Even if Bilbo had made it to Mount Doom , he would n’t have had Sam , whose dedication to Frodo and reason of the Ring are vital to its wipeout .
Conversely , Bilbo has more material desires than Frodo . Though the way he use the Ring throughout his life are relatively innocent , they prove that the Ring would ’ve had an easier time using him as a tool of Mordor . Even if Bilbo had made it to Mount Doom , he would n’t have had Sam , whose allegiance to Frodo and agreement of the Ring are vital to its wipeout . Additionally , without Gollum , the Ring would n’t have been destruct at all , and the kindness that Frodo shows Gollum inThe Lord of the Ringsplays into Gollum ’s legal action at the end of the story .
