Related
J.R.R. Tolkien’sLord of the Ringsis a complex story made up of countless layers , but now and then , a lover theory comes along and shifts the whole matter . Of course , this serial has been around for closely a C , so those who love Tolkien ’s workplace have had a long metre to ruminate about the goings on within the various tales and risky venture . With twelve of characters and happenings , there are countless chance for developing theory . Some are rather unconscionable , while others are entirely plausible . OtherLord of the Ringstheories can change how we comprehend the overarching stories .
I have been aLord of the Ringsfan for 25 years , and I , confessedly , turn my nose up at a heavy many fan theory . For one , Tolkien himself disprove pop theoriesthrough his various responses to letters . However , a few are deserving nurse for a few moments , if only to regard how they wobble our perspectives . This often total down to the unspoken intentions of certain characters or the various ways that the narrators ofThe HobbitandThe Lord of the Ringsare undependable . Sure , not all of these are probable to be rightful — but what if they were ?
5Gollum Killed Frodo’s Parents
A Theory That Adds Even More Irony To Gollum & Frodo’s Destinies
This hypothesis is one that I can buy into far more readily . Frodo ’s parent , Drogo and Primula Baggins die out about 20 years before theevents ofThe Lord of the Ringswhen they suffered a boating chance event . Little is do it about the details of this , but it ’s confirmed that the twosome drowned . This fact revolutionize the theory thatDrogo and Primula were attacked by Gollum , who was looking for his treasured Ring .
Gollum is an expert swimmer , and his general history with water makes Drogo and Primula ’s deaths right up his alley . If the creature sincerely was responsible for , it makes Bilbo part with Gollum and Frodo later taking pity on him even more ironic . Had Bilbo kill Gollum , then Frodo would never have been orphaned . Then again , Gollum also would n’t have been there to destroy the One Ring , either .
4Gandalf Wanted To Take The Eagles To Mordor
A Theory That Completely Changes Gandalf’s “Final” Words
One of my least favorite arguments against the world-wide story ofThe Lord of the Ringsis that the Fellowship should have tease the Eagles to Mordor . This is n’t much of a plot hole since stealth was the full point of the Fellowship ’s deputation . However , the estimation becomes more interesting when considering that the Eagles might have agree within Gandalf ’s original program .
This hypothesis suggest that Gandalf ’s last word , " Fly , you fools , " was in reality a hint .
InThe Lord of the Rings : The Fellowship of the Ring , Gandalf initially wanted to get to the other side of the Misty Mountains — the big question was whether they would go over or under the mountain range . A theory has develop that he intended to head North to conform to up with the Eagles and asking that they take Frodo on the next leg of his journey . Of naturally , Gandalf could n’t share his plan since he died in Moria . This possibility propose that Gandalf ’s final words , " Fly , you fools , " was actually a suggestion .
3Sam, Merry, & Pippin Were “Backup” Hobbits
A Theory That Puts A Darker Spin On Gandalf’s Tough Decisions
It ’s readable throughoutThe Lord of the Ringsthat Gandalf saw a lot of potential in Hobbits . This is generally considered a good thing , but there is a bit of a benighted angle to detect here as well . Gandalf was a retainer to the will of Eru Ilúvatar and was clever enough to recognize that the god of Middle - earth had created beings uniquely able of managing Sauron ’s malefic arm . Gandalf recognise that Hobbits were meant to be Sauron ’s fall .
Of course , Gandalf would also have recognized that any Ring - bearer would be doomed . He hate that this fall to Frodo , but Gandalf could only travel along Eru Ilúvatar ’s plan as well he could . It ’s a bit heartless to retrieve of it this way , but when regard the darker side of Frodo ’s circumstances , it certainly seems thatGandalf concord to bring Sam , Merry , and Pippin along just in pillowcase Frodo failed . If this is genuine , then the Hobbits were fundamentally disposable soldier .
Gandalf succeeded in his journey because he trust the will of Eru Ilúvatar while his fellow Istari looked to their own desire . In Gandalf ’s case , that think not putting the lives of the Hobbits above the fate of Middle - earth .
2Gandalf Only Pretended Not To Understand The Doors Of Durin
A Theory That Changes Frodo’s Clever Solution
I will intromit that Gandalf ’s inability to solve the " speak acquaintance and enter " riddle on the Doors of Durin was a mo hard to swallow . He sat outside the doors for a rather long time inThe Lord of the Rings : The Fellowship of the Ring , but he seemed unable to sort it out . Thankfully , Frodo was there to suggest that the parole was the elfish Scripture for " booster , " encouraging Gandalf to literally " speak acquaintance " to enter the Dwarven realm .
While I do n’t believe Gandalf would give Frodo the choice if he did n’t mean it , it ’s still interesting to debate the mavin ’s fiber from this slant .
In solvent to the ridiculousness of this situation , a devotee theory develop suggesting that Gandalf had n’t been trying to get inside Moria . After all , the superstar had repeatedly posit that he wanted to avoid the dark-skinned cave . Gandalf leave it up to Frodo , but perhaps he hop the Fellowship would twist back if it took too retentive to enter . While I do n’t think Gandalf would give Frodo the option if he did n’t mean it , it ’s still interesting to consider the wizard ’s type from this angle .
1The Lord Of The Rings Is A Lie Written By Sam
A Theory That Completely Changes Frodo & Sam’s Ending
Tolkien did n’t approach TheLord of the Ringsas a narration he wrote himself . rather , he treated it like an ancient text he get a line and transform , publishing it asThe Lord of the Rings . In Middle - earthly concern , the story is kept within the Red Book of Westmarch , which was ab initio written by Bilbo beforeFrodo and Samadded their own stories to it .
It has been think by someLord of the Ringsfans thatFrodo actually died during his adventures , falling target to the One Ring and his trauma . To make Frodo sound well ( and to will a happier ending for his friend ) , Sam wrote Frodo ’s adventures in the Book of Wesmarch — but the immense majority of it was a lie . This is quite tragical to deliberate , and while this theory is n’t great for Frodo , it only further encourages what a devoted friend Sam was inThe Lord of the Rings.
Custom image by Yeider Chacon
