Home Economics
home plate Economicswas a criminally unawares - lived situation comedy that both build on the winner ofModern Family ’s templet and improved some of its biggest weakness . Modern Familywas a wildly successful mockumentary that make for divers representation of what a kinsperson can count like into people ’s living rooms . The final season ofModern Familyaired in 2020 , but many element of the show already feel outdated , especially compared to the sitcom that would debut on the same meshwork just a yr later .
Modern Familyexplored the dynamics between three branches of a familyin Los Angeles . Home Economics , by line , concentrate on on three grownup sibling and their family in San Francisco , as the oldest brother prepare to write a book about their lives . Both series showcase different type of marriages , ethnicities , and financial situations , butHome Economicsavoids lean into troubling stereotypes thatModern Familynever soften over its 11 seasons .
Similarities & Differences Between Home Economics and Modern Family
Home Economics and Modern Family Treat Diversity Differently
The law of similarity betweenModern FamilyandHome Economicsare undeniable . The two shows are both ensemble situational comedies about families pilot their relationships with each other . Each series sport three main branches of the family , including a homophile couple and an interracial couple . Likewise , bothHome EconomicsandModern Familyuse framing devices , although whereModern Familyuses a mockumentary format , which allows for utter head consultation , Home Economicsis recite through the perspective of the eldest brother write a playscript about the family line .
InModern Family , economical differences between family members are address , but money is the central hook ofHome political economy …
A cardinal point of difference is how finance element into both shows . InModern Family , economic differences between phratry penis are addressed , but money is the central hook ofHome Economics : three siblings , each in a dissimilar socio - economical stratum . Modern Familytakes more of an intergenerational approachthrough the electron lens of the patriarch , and particularly in the later seasons , with increased storylines given to the youngest generation .
While Modern Family is one of the most popular sitcoms in recent age , Reddit buff are sharing some here and now that feel cringeworthy .
Although both appearance have comparable family setup , variety is treat very differently betweenModern FamilyandHome Economics . Modern Familybrought homophile marriage and adoption into a mainstream comedy , butMitchell Pritchett and Cameron Tucker were often bicker and rarely physically affectionate , undersell the delight of sustain gay representation . Mitch and Cam did not have their first osculation until the 2nd season , after fans ofModern Familycriticized the want of forcible trace in the relationship . Conversely , Sarah and Denise Hayworth ’s relationship inHome Economicsis loving and attender – one vista that established the series as a unlike kind of show .
How Marina and Gloria’s Ethnicities Factor into Home Economics and Modern Family
Modern Family Leans On Stereotypes While Home Economics Pushes Deeper
InModern Family , Jay Pritchett and Gloria Delgado - Pritchett bring a blended , interracial marriage to the small screen , butGloria ’s Colombian inheritance is uncomfortably exoticized . Sofía Vergara ’s Gloria tilt into Latino stereotype : a fiery pique , outfits designed to highlight her curves , an overprotective nature when it come to her son . Gloria ’s accent and English are also on a regular basis mock . In one episode , she even angrily asks her husband : “ Do you know how bright I am in Spanish ? ” Even Gloria play into these exaggerated stereotypes , with lines like : “ Do you know how many time I was taken hostage growing up ? ” thrown out nonchalantly .
Sofía Vergara is a rude blonde , but she was encouraged to dye her fuzz dark as this is the expect facial expression for a Latina on video .
InHome Economics , Marina Hayworth is Mexican - American , but it leans into the comedy and defeat of being a soul of color in a snowy household . InHome Economicsseason 2 , instalment 4 , Marina is horrified to realize her girl , Camila , knows more about Marvel ’s Thor than Mexico ’s Freida Kahlo . Marina tells her husband , Tom , through tears that she take in she has give up making an elbow grease to keep her heritage alive . Tom come up Camila sing the babies to kip with a Spanish lullaby Marina used to sing to her , and Tom show Marina that perhaps she is authorize on more than she acknowledge .
Marina ’s sis - in - legal philosophy , Denise Hayworth , is black-market . When Denise points out the macaroni salad at brunch as evidence of whiteness , Marina confesses she brought the macaroni salad with the excellent line reading of : “ The Patrick White is coming from inside the house ! ”
BothHome EconomicsandModern Familyaddress slipstream and racism . However , whereModern Familyoften relies on uncomfortable stereotypes as a germ of humour , menage Economicsis much more nuanced in its handling of complicated theme . With the benefit of hindsight , this retrospectively improves the late show , putting it firm on the ripe side of chronicle when it comes to one of the delimit prospect of forward-looking phratry animation .
Why Was Home Economics Canceled After Just Three Seasons?
Several Factors Kept Viewers From Finding Home Economics
Home Economicsran from 2021 to 2023 , but the situation comedy never quite found its audience and was canceled due to low viewership after three seasons . base Economicsfaced unshakable competition in the situation comedy marketplace . Young Sheldon , The Connors , The Goldbergs , andblack - ishwere contemporary , well - established folk sitcom , andHome Economics’freshman season was vie with the first seasons ofAbbott ElementaryandGhosts , both of which are still on the air .
Home Economicsdid not have the star great power to guide in witness . Topher Grace ( That ‘ 70s Show ) and Karla Souza ( How to Get Away with Murder ) were the most recognisable name , but Ed O’Neil was already a situation comedy legend fromMarried … with Children . moreover , abode Economicspremiered in 2021 , when telecasting was still line up to changing viewership habits during the pandemic . Nevertheless , despite its struggles , the show ’s sensitivity when it came to manage delicate storylines has stood the test of time .
